What Are Comment Pods?
In an online version of: “I’ll scratch your back, if you scratch my back”, comment pods are another way of trying to fool both other users and the popularity algorithms on social media platforms.
It’s a lot of effort to go to, creating a false narrative for your account, pretending that your account is more popular than it really is using fake activity.
If you’re not familiar, comment pods (also known as engagement pods) are groups of people who agree to like, comment, and share each other’s posts on social media, particularly Instagram. The idea is to boost engagement rates, tricking algorithms into thinking the content is popular and should be shown to more people.
At first glance, it might seem like a smart hack for growing your audience. However, if you’re a music artist, this strategy can backfire in several ways.
Table of Contents
Comment Pods
Comment pods or engagement pods are Instagram users collected together in cooperating user groups, to like and comment on each other’s posts. Pod members work together to increase their reach. When a pod member makes a post, they share a link to the post with fellow pod members. The pod members then like and comment on the post. It’s a tactic designed to boost the reach of that post artificially.
The mechanics may vary, but there are similar ways of cooperating on Twitter, Facebook, and other social media. On other platforms sharing, quoting, and tagging are added to like and comment as ways of boosting reach.
The issue is that agreeing to like, comment, or share content, no matter if it is content they really like or want to engage with, is highly counterproductive.
Why Are Comment Pods A Bad Idea?
You need only understand the very basic principles of the way that social media algorithms work, to see a number of common artist habits that are a really bad idea.
Social media companies have spent millions upon millions investing in their algorithms. They do this so that their software can work out what you like, what you are interested in. They do it so their software can work out what others like about you and what they find interesting about you.
llamcorper mattis, pulvinar dapibus leo.
Why Comment Pods Are Risky for Musicians?
1. Fake Engagement, Fake Audience: While you might get more comments or likes on your posts, these are often from other pod members, not genuine fans of your music. This creates a skewed perception of your popularity. You might have hundreds of likes on a post, but when you release new music, no one listens because the engagement was superficial.
2. Algorithm Confusion: Social media algorithms are designed to show your content to people who are likely to engage with it. If your posts are being liked and commented on by people who aren’t actually interested in your music, the algorithm might start showing your content to the wrong audience. This can hurt your reach over time, as your posts aren’t getting in front of the people who would genuinely appreciate your art.
3. Wasted Time: Being in a comment pod requires time and effort. You have to engage with other people’s content, which can be time-consuming. This is time that could be better spent writing songs, producing music, or engaging with real fans.
4. Inauthenticity: Fans can tell when engagement feels forced or inauthentic. If your comments sections are full of generic comments from other artists or influencers, it can be a turn-off for potential fans who are looking for real connections.
5. Negative Reputation: Being known as someone who participates in engagement pods can damage your reputation. Industry professionals, such as labels or PR agents, can often spot fake engagement, which might lead them to question the authenticity of your following and your potential as an artist.
Better Strategies for Building an Authentic Audience
Instead of relying on comment pods, here are some tactics you can use to build a real, engaged audience for your music:
1. Quality Over Quantity: Focus on creating high-quality content that resonates with your audience. Whether it’s a behind-the-scenes look at your creative process, a live performance, or a personal story, genuine content is more likely to attract real fans.
2. Engage Genuinely: Take the time to inter: Instead of joining a comment pod, collaborate with other musicians. This could be through features, co-writing, or even just sharing each other’s music. This way, you’re reaching audiences who are already interested in your genre.
4. Use Hashtags Wisely: Hashtags are a great way to get discovered by new audiences, but it’s important to use them correctly. Research and use hashtags that are relevant to your music, genre, and message. Don’t go overboard; a mix of popular and niche hashtags usually works best.
5. Leverage Social Media Ads: If you have a budget, consider running ads on platforms like Instagram, Facebook, or TikTok. These allow you to target specific demographics, ensuring your music reaches the right people. Even a small investment can make a big difference if targeted correctly.
6. Consistent Posting Schedule: Be consistent with your posting schedule. This doesn’t mean you have to post every day, but regular updates help keep your audience engaged and coming back for more.
7. Email Lists: While social media is important, don’t overlook the power of an email list. Emails give you direct access to your fans without the interference of algorithms. You can use it to announce new releases, tours, or exclusive content.
8. Engage in Relevant Communities: Instead of generic engagement pods, find communities of people who love the type of music you create. This could be online forums, Facebook groups, or even Reddit threads. Engaging in these spaces can help you find people who are genuinely interested in your music.
9. Go Live: Platforms like Instagram, YouTube, and Facebook allow you to go live, which is a great way to connect with your audience in real time. You can perform, answer questions, or even just chat with your fans. Live interactions are often more meaningful and can help you build a stronger connection with your audience.
10. Storytelling: People love stories. Whether it’s the story behind a song, your journey as an artist, or a personal anecdote, sharing stories can make your audience feel more connected to you. Use captions, videos, and even Instagram Stories to tell your story.
Final Thoughts
While comment pods might seem like an easy shortcut to growing your audience, the risks often outweigh the rewards. As a musician, it’s crucial to build a fanbase that is genuinely interested in your music. By focusing on quality content, authentic engagement, and targeted strategies, you can grow an audience that not only loves your music but will stick around for the long haul. In the end, it’s about creating meaningful connections that can lead to a successful and fulfilling music career.
Related Articles
Do you want to find out more about independent music artists here on Songstuff? If so, you can find articles and interviews on our Indie Music Blog page.
Read more about the music business and music marketing in the Songstuff Music Business Articles.
Useful Links
Music Library
Are you looking for advice about writing songs or writing lyrics? Recording or music production? Or maybe your music is ready for release and you are looking for help and advice about releasing and marketing your songs. Check out our library of music articles and tutorials:
Songstuff Music Community
In addition to our extensive article library and tutorials you can discuss writing songs, recording and music production as well as how to release and market your music, and building your fan base in the Songstuff Music Community.
You might want to talk over something you read to help make your understanding clear, or to pass on a new understanding to another songwriter. Maybe you just want to share your songs? Or just chat to fellow lyricists, songwriters, musicians, artists or producers? If so, please:
Members and staff are friendly and welcoming.
If you are already a member you can go directly to the Music Community:
Useful Boards
We also have a critique board that is only visible to members. This may be particularly useful for songwriters who are restricted by a record contract or publishing contract.
Interesting Topics
Music Glossary
To help you to understand specific terms, take a look at our Music Glossary. It has extensive descriptions of music technology terms and concepts. It also contains entries about music theory and terms from across the music industry including music marketing and music promotion.
Songstuff Media Player
If you would like to listen to some awesome indie music while you browse, just open our media player. It opens in another window (or tab) so your playlist can play uninterrupted as you browse.
Open the Songstuff Media Player.
Playlists are curated by SsUK for the Independent Music Stage and Songstuff.